Is Netflix Streaming Good Enough for the Serious Movie Buff?  
Home Theater Feature Articles Video Related Articles
Written by Thomas Spurlin   
Wednesday, 23 December 2009

Since 1997, Netflix has changed the way that we think about "renting" movies.  Instead of schlepping it to our nearest big box rental shop or mom 'n pop store to pick up a tape of DVD, they've made us all lazier -- excuse me, enhanced the convenience of renting a movie -- by sending discs directly to our mailbox based on a queue arranged on their website.  Wait times can be a hassle for high-demand items, but the service has nevertheless made believers out of many consumers.  However, with the likes of free movies available at various venues across the Internet (Hulu, The Auteurs), a new type of viewing experience has become predominant within the past few years: instant streaming, along with free on-demand rentals through cable providers.

In reaction to this, Netflix has also come out of the gate with movies available to play instantly via their streaming service -- though it's only become available on specific standalone Blu-ray players (such as LG’s BD300), as well as on the computer itself.  Well, Netflix has again tinkered with the way we think about viewing movies in the home by trumpeting out instant streaming via gaming units, first with the Xbox 360 earlier this year and now with a newly-fangled Streaming Disc for the popular Playstation 3.  The marriage between the Playstation 3 and this new streaming disc is a naturally stellar union, offering a highly-integrated, quick, and intuitive process to entry.

Netflix Instant Streaming Disc

 Setup:

Getting the PS3 set up for the streaming disc is pretty easy.  First step is to send a request to the company for a disc, done here (http://www.netflix.com/InstantStreamingDisc). Since the mailing is handled by the local distribution centers, it should arrive on your doorstep in about the same timeframe as receiving any other disc in the mail -- roughly two days.  It arrives in the signature red envelope just like the other discs from the service, only with bright writing that states that the user doesn't have to return the disc at any point. A second sleeve, similar to a standard DVR slip, also comes with the disc to protect it when it's not in the machine.

Once it arrives, it's a really straightforward process: insert the disc, access the Netflix option in the "Video" row of the XMB (if you don't have Auto Load turned on), and wait for it to load on the system.  Once it boots up, the user will need to communicate a code via the Internet to "pair" up the individual PS3 system to the account.  It asks if you "already have your Netflix streaming disc", making a field available on the website where said code, which will pop up on your screen, can be entered. That process happens almost instantaneously. After the two have been linked, the system's ready for streaming.  

Categories and Instant Queue:

Once it's loaded, the navigational interface is both nicely laid out and very pleasing.  File tabs appear at the top, which can be "flipped" through with the directional buttons on the PS3 controller (or the directional pad on the Bluetoothe Blu-ray remote).The Instant Streaming framework comes equipped with several standard options to surf through, including New Arrivals, Recently Watched, basic categories (Comedy, Sci-Fi & Fantasy, etc.), and a few elaborate categories (Serial-Killer Thrillers, Movies About Weddings, Raunchy Movies, etc.).  Each of the categories typically has twenty-five (25) suggestions, and some of the offerings are rather respectable at the start -- including the likes of Full Metal Jacket, Blade Runner, and modern hits like The International.

Netflix Catagoies and Instant Queue

What makes the Instant Streaming infinitely valuable is the first folder, the Instant Queue.  The user can built their list of movies to watch by browsing, searching, and adding titles on the Netflix home website, all of which pop up very shortly after it's done.  This feature is available by clicking on the "Watch Instantly" tab at the top of the home web address, further refined by categories directly underneath the main bar.   Genres range from Action & Adventure and Horror to Faith & Spirituality, as well as a category specifically set aside for high-definition (HD) films.  Every film either has an "Add" or "Save" button underneath the cover artwork; however, the films available for Instant Streaming are annotated with a blue "Play" button.  Hovering over that blue button makes a second option pop up underneath, "Add to Instant Queue".  Simply click on that button and the network will update the selection. 

Each film has a home page that has a small interface at the top that enables playing the film / TV episode, giving a star rating between one (1) and five (5), and removing it from the Instant Queue.  Underneath all that, some descriptors for the film / TV episode are available: a small cast listing, a synopsis for the film, runtime, year the film came out, the director, and its category.  For instance, Federico Fellini's Amarcord flops firmly in the "Foreign Classics" section.   To activate the film, click on the "play" option and wait for the film to pop up.  Wait times for the content to begin streaming vary, but they're mostly very quick -- taking roughly 20-30 seconds to load up.

Performance:

Netflix tailors its streaming service to the speed of your internet connection, without downloading anything to the hard drive, to ensure the best quality image possible based on individual setups.  Via high-speed internet and a wireless connection going to a slimline PS3, the quality for standard-definition content comes in mostly just a few steps underneath DVD quality -- that is, just a step or two underneath the most recent DVD.  It's all going to depend on the source, varying between slapdash cable replications from partnered networks to crisp quality images that come very close to retail sharpness.  Furthermore, some digging around in the catalog will give you access to a few movies that don't currently have in-print DVDs (such as Love Me If You Dare, as of this writing).  To top it off, there are many full season TV sets to sift through, with an intuitive episode-by-episode toggle that changes after each one is finished.

Play Screen

After watching a handful of films available in both anamorphic and non-anamorphic presentations on home video, many of the prints range from looking very similar to their retail counterparts to drastically different and, sadly, incorrect.  Let's get the negatives out of the way first. The print damage from 10 Things I Hate About You looked similar through an aliased yet colorful widescreen-enhanced image, about what it looks like to zoom in on the non-anamorphic disc, but From Dusk 'til Dawn comes out full-framed and looking rather drab. 

On the flipside of things, the presentation for Chris Marker's La Jetee (sourced from Criterion / Janus, of which there are plenty) was properly framed at 1.66:1 and Tell No One at 2.35:1 -- both truthful to the director's intent and of very high quality.  It's worth noting that full-frame sources, tested by both "The Office" (UK) and Tetsuo: The Iron Man, come out as stretched 4x3 material even if the selection for "Normal" upscaling is elected from the Video Settings menu.  Also, all the audio cranks out as a non-dynamic 2.0 Stereo sound track, but it never distorts, blips, or cuts out.

There's another side of the Netflix Instant Streaming: HD content.  Two films were tested, Ballast and The Last Detail, each one offered in mostly correct aspect ratios (Ballast at 2.35:1, The Last Detail at 1.78:1) and in low bitrate AVC encodes.  Naturally, the results will differ based on the source material, but the quality wasn't anything to scoff at.  Yes, compression artifacts grow a bit heavier than Blu-ray tech and detail isn't nearly as pronounced, but the leap in clarity over standard-definition is very respectable and about on-par with HD offerings on cable channels.  Again, the big crippling aspect is the sound option, only available on 2.0 Stereo -- not uncompressed PCM, but run-of-the-mill Stereo.  Print damage for The Last Detail resembles the standard-definition counterpart as well, which is pleasing but desperately needing a clean-up job.

Final Impressions:


Those who subscribe to Netflix and own a Playstation 3 will certainly find this to be a no brainer: take the time out and send a request to the company for a streaming disc.  The selection of content available for immediate viewing is outstanding.  The quality is passable, considering the instant accesibility, and the speed of communication is very, very appealing. Since the streaming service doesn't interfere with the disc distribution -- almost operating as separate entities -- it'll come in handy if you're a one-disc subscriber and waiting for your next disc. 

The SD quality obviously isn't as good as on standard DVD, nor HD quality compared to Blu-ray, especially when considering the audio, but it may be a tolerable gap depending on your needs. Now, whether this new streaming service is enough of a selling point to cough up $9 for Netflix, if you aren't subscribing yet, is a pretty easy question to answer.  Those finicky with quality won't be very fond of the audio limitations and may want to stick to physical media. But for those seeking immediate access, the myriad of films available for instant viewing easily makes the entry price worth the subscription fee.

   Comments
Add New | Search
  
Ali Zaimi  - Enthusiastic Netflix Fan     |2009-12-24 04:36:08
This is the best thing since sliced bread. I heard from a friend of mine about
5 years ago that he was a Netflix subscriber. I didn't know much about Netflix
until I bought my Xbox 360 2 years ago. Sure enough, Xbox played a vital role
in getting my wife and I hooked on it.

Who cares about waiting for new
releases. It still is better than making countless stops to Blockbuster waiting
on a New Release to be returned from a previous renter. Their instant que is
the bees knees. :)

I recommend giving Netflix gift cards to everyone this
holiday season as an economical way of giving a great gift for only $9.00 per
month.
Allen Lentz  - Netflix Bandwith   |2009-12-24 12:34:05
Netflix streaming is certainly convenient, but the quality is awful. It actually
looks worse than "old fashioned" TV from the '70s.
You need serious
bandwith for streaming video and the US doesn't have it, yet many foreign
counties do. Until we have significant broadband speeds, I expect streaming
video to continue to "dumb down" the average viewer's expectations.

If
you are reading this, you probably know and care about image and sound quality.
I don't see how any serious AV fan can stand to watch streaming video when they
can get a BluRay (or even standard DVD from Netflix so easily.
Paul  - Better than cable   |2009-12-24 12:36:49
Since Comcast switched over to digital cable if you don't rent their digital
cable box The Netflix picture is much better than the unwatchable junk from
Comcast.
Tom Becker  - Not there yet   |2009-12-24 12:54:53
For the serious movie buff? Not even close. The catalog is so limited and the
HD, while watchable, is very very compressed. I compare it to the compression
U-Verse uses. We will never have a mirrored disc to streaming offering but it's
fun to dream.
Peter Tribeman  - President Atlantic Tecnology   |2009-12-25 06:32:03
Like the I-Pod. it is enormously convenient. However, for those who still care
about reproducing something infinitely close to the very best theaters, it is
still a big compromise.

For well crafted films, 2.0 sound just doesn't cut
it. Ad for the video artifacts are still visible.

From what we have read,
the Vudu technology appears much more advanced. While not perfect, reports are
that it is approaching Blu-Ray quality. In addition, the sound is delivered in
Dolby Digital Plus-not True HD, but still pretty close.

In all I would say
that Netflix is off to a reasonable start . But they have a way to go to catch
up to the Vudu reference standard.
Chris  - "The Man"   |2009-12-25 12:46:16
So, what's the plan for the Wii? I heard a long time ago that they were
planning on adding instant streaming to the Wii w/ a similar system, but there
hasn't been any news recently.

Also, like everyone else these days, you used
the word "myriad" incorrectly.
FinanceBuzz  - Netflix Streaming not ready for primetime     |2009-12-25 18:14:50
I have and Xbox 360 and just the other night I thought I would give Netflix
streaming another chance. Sorry, but this service is just not ready to be my
primary method of watching "DVD" content. It is slow to stop and reload
with all the buffering. Part way through what I was watching, it stops and
throttles back the video quality due to speed. It is much easier and quicker to
rewind/fast-forward on a DVD. Granted, I do not have fiber-level internet speed
(mid-tier on AT&T is the fastest I can get at my home) but, as someone else
alluded to, until serious bandwidth is available to the home, I do not intend to
give up my newly setup Blu-Ray player.
Home Theater  - I think I'll stick with the Vudu     |2009-12-25 22:01:56
I've had a Vudu since before they were released for retail sale, and it has
improved tremendously in quality and selection. Maybe Netflix steaming will
experience a similar advance as the service matures.

As other have indicated
however, not having true, digital surround sound is a deal breaker for me. When
I can either get Blu-Ray video quality or a small step down with the Vudu, it is
tough to recommend Netflix. The Vudu has a greater selection of content as
well, especially in 1080p HD.
Enthusiast  - PS3 all the way   |2009-12-28 05:00:25
If anyone gives this option with Netflix a thumbs down, they don't know what
they are talking about. I have had Netflix for about 6 years. The $22 that I
shell out for the 3 movies at a time is perfect for anyone....If you call
yourself a movie enthusiast. Now that they supply Blu-Ray for 99% of all new
releases, as long as you are smart with your que, you will get what you want.


Now that they added the "Instant Viewing" option for the PS3, I feel
I am getting something AWESOME for nothing. Unlike the X360, you don't have to
pay to view on the PS3. XBOX you have to have LIVE....Which I refused to pay to
have internet gaming access. Now Netflix is sticking it to Microsoft by offering
their customers the PS3 option.

The biggest bonus that I found with the PS3
Instant Streaming is watching movies in HD. Yes the audio is not 5.1, and the HD
movies available are sort of limited, but remember my phrase?....Something
awesome for nothing....I read someone on this comment section complaining about
their not being a great selection. That is wrong and that is someone expecting
too much for nothing.

I see this moving toward Netflix charging people to
get new released HD movies via instant streaming. When that happens I will have
another decision to make. As it stands now, I am extremely happy.
D in Dallas  - Great Bonus to have   |2009-12-29 14:18:08
AS a Netlix "member", this is a terrific bonus to have. PS3 streaming
is great for TV shows, documentaries, an old classics. We get decent quality
and no dropouts or lag on my FIOS. It complements watching movies on blu-ray
for a complete service nicely. Very useful and convenient.
Rugby   |2010-01-10 13:03:22
Netflix has my vote...I am able to stream movies thru sony blueray player to my
55" LCD TV and simultaneously downstream the same movie or a different one
on my PC and pass it through to my 32" LCD TV in my office..quality is fine,
video and audio. It only gets better.
p  - ASPECT RATIO ISSUES   |2010-03-04 16:27:35
I seem to be having issues when it comes to streaming a movie that is in the
2.35:1 aspect ratio. A 2.35:1 movie should have some black on top and bottom on
an HDTV. But It seems that the picture is just stretching to the screen edges -
so the image fills the 16:9 screen. - This leaves the image still stretched up
and down - - - When playing the same movie on a computer - it is displayed
properly as 2.35: 1 - - has anyone encountered this problem - -
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."






Like this article? Bookmark and share with any of the sites below.
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!StumbleUpon!Yahoo!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
 
Joomla SEF URLs by Artio