equipment reviews
This Month's Featured Equipment Reviews
SVS Ultra Bookshelf Loudspeaker Review
Opera Mezza Loudspeakers Review
Vanatoo Transparent One Powered Monitors Review
HiFiMan RE-400 In-Ear Monitor Review
Marantz SA-11S3 SACD Player & DAC Review
Latest AV News
Blu-ray Hardware Forum Topics:
Classic Video Players Reviews
Past Blu-ray Hardware News
 
Sony BDP-S350 Blu-ray Player  Print E-mail
Home Theater Video Players Blu-ray Players
Written by Tom Volotta   
Monday, 02 February 2009
Article Index
Sony BDP-S350 Blu-ray Player 
Page 2
Page 3
Page 4
Page 5

BD-Live:

BD-Live is the latest incarnation of connecting local disc-based content with real-time, remote and in some cases, multiple user interactivity.  WebDVD applications could do it to some extent with DVDs, but were almost exclusively confined to playback on a computer.  Profile 2.0 gives set top BD players that capability, and with today’s faster broadband, more efficient compression techniques and a new generation of users plugged in to social networking, the opportunity for this to work exists.  Content is still the key, though, and in these early stages, the pickings are slim for BD-Live.

Connecting to your title’s BD-Live network can be tedious.   Initiating it is easy:  just click on BD-Live from within the title’s menu. The Hollywood studios have their own systems to deliver this material and vary greatly in what’s offered and how to get there.

Disney (WALL-E) is by far the most sophisticated network and expansive range of features.  Paramount (Iron Man) has the least in terms of offering, but you can also access their BD-Live system easier.  Warner (The Dark Knight) is in the middle.

Disney BD-Live
The Disney BD-Live Interface

All require you to register with an email address, user name, and password and in most cases, a home address.  An on-screen keyboard allows using the player’s remote control arrow and enter keys to submit info.  Disney is the most rigorous in qualifying users, citing their family orientation and concern for security.  After the initial registration though the Blu-ray player, the studios process and send you a confirming email to then log back into BD-Live through the player.  Customer support needs some upgrading all around, as requests to have passwords resent can take days for a response.

Iron Man had only a simple, multiple choice, time-based (the quicker you select the correct answer, the more points) trivia game available.  BD-Live isn’t necessary to implement that, but apparently so many people wanted to explore Iron Man BD-Live that Paramount’s site crashed when the BDs were first released. Warner had a few more interactive features available for TDK, including downloads of movie trailers and live special events such as the one with director Christopher Nolan. But Disney is head and shoulders above them all.  The BDisney-Live Network, although not yet fully decked out, has numerous options for playing private games or against online opponents, social networking to chat with friends during a movie, promotions, Movie Rewards and more to come.  Disney has announced they will integrate the use of laptops, iPhone & iTouch and other interface devices to eliminate the cumbersome navigation and data entry via the BD player remote.

The Sony S350 operated reasonably well in BD-Live.  It’s a far cry from using the Internet from your computer, but content and performance upgrades should improve the experience.

Note:  Even though the S350 may be running its most up-to-date firmware, you will be prompted from time to time by the respective BD-Live sites to update their software.  Do that.  Considerable development is underway for BD-Live applications.  Just how much the audience for Blu-ray packaged media wants all these extra interactive - what some might call interruptive - additions to the movie experience remains to be seen. 

Conclusion:


It’s hard to knock the Sony BDP-S350.  The machine does its job, is dependable, quiet, built solid and looks good in delivering the key features for a Blu-ray player, all at a reasonable entry-level price. Spending a few bucks for a 1GB Flash drive and upgrading the player’s firmware instantly makes the S350 into a full Profile 2.0, BD-Live machine.  Some traditional features like still frame advance and reverse aren’t available, and the on screen display could reveal more information about elapsed, remaining and total time simultaneously.  I had a few quibbles with the arrangement of settings in the Xross interface, but these are minor, especially if connecting your BDP-S350 to your AV system via HDMI 1.3 and using Easy Setup to configure the defaults to get up and running with the least hassle for optimum viewing and listening pleasure.

One closing trivial nit to pick:  When you have a Blu-ray disc loaded in the player and click Home to access the S350’s menu, under Video you’ll see a graphic rectangle with a disc in the center.  It’s labeled “BD-ROM.”  That’s the movie you’re going to watch! Why so techy calling it BD-ROM?  I know, I know, it is a Blu-ray Read Only Memory disc, and the Blu-ray Disc Association doesn’t have all the format variations the DVD Forum has for DVD-Video, DVD-Audio, DVD-R, DVD+R and so on.  But I’m watching a movie here!  Just call it “Blu-ray” or “Blu-ray Disc” in the user interface.  Maybe even display the title.  The BDP-S350 is certainly smart enough to do that.

   Comments
Add New | Search
  
Butch Patchell   |2009-02-03 08:51:31
THE major feature of the newest BD players is their ability to decode the latest
uncompressed audio formats...and you review this player on a system lacking that
ability!!? Sound is a huge factor in home theater. We want to know, "How
does it sound?"
Tom Volotta   |2009-02-05 17:11:43
You are partially correct. I do regret not having access to HDMI-equipped audio
gear to listen to and evaluate the new high definition audio formats. However,
on the specific point of 'decoding the latest uncompressed audio formats...' the
Sony BDP-S350 Blu-ray player does NOT have that capability, nor have the
necessary output jacks. The next step up in Sony's line, the BDP-S550 does. The
S350 only outputs the newest HD formats via HDMI 1.3 bitstream.

Whether
"THE major feature" for new Blu-ray players is decoding advanced HD
formats is a matter of opinion. Personally, I'd rather leave that job to
separate audio equipment with superior decoding and processing. If you already
have sound gear that can accept and accurately reproduce the full spectrum of
new HD uncompressed audio formats, you're already operating above the
entry-level product category, which the Sony S350 is.
Tom Volotta  - Response continued...   |2009-02-05 17:08:10
That said, I agree completely that sound, and especially surround sound, is one
of the great pleasures of the movie experience at home.
I will be upgrading my
system shortly to more fully appreciate and enjoy the new audio formats.

- TV
Marc M   |2009-02-18 03:35:32
I do not believe that the BDP-S350 will allow for bitstream output of Dolby True
HD or DTS HD over HDMI and that is one of the feature differences (and thus the
main reason for buying) for the BDP-S550. The BDP-S350 causes my Integra DTC-9.8
to default to "multi-channel" on its displayed surround modes whereas
the BDP-S550 will activate display of "True HD". Am I wrong on this?
Gerald Bohmer   |2009-02-18 07:11:32
I am still exploring this "Brave New World" of HD. My A/V amp is an
older Sansui, offering only RCA inputs for for audio, with S-video the only
additional option on the video side. It does have Dolby Pro-logic sound
processing, which was the best available when I purchased it. I'm not prepared
to upgrade all of my equipment at the same time. I am grateful that Sony has
seen fit to offer the older connection options. I appreciate ther information I
receive from AV-Rev, even if I can't just go out and buy the latest & greatest.
Butch Patchell   |2009-02-18 08:01:45
Even without a receiver capable of decoding the lossless formats, the audio
output for both Dolby® and DTS® is nearly double the data rate of DVD. The sound
on my 5.1 system is extraordinary and a noticeable step up from DVD. I'm really
looking forward to updating my pre/pro to one capable of decoding the latest
formats.

To Marc M:
The following is from Sony's website on the technical
capabilities of the BD-S350.

Audio Features

* Dolby® : Yes, & Dolby®
TrueHD bitstream out over HDMI
Bob Hitson  - BDP S350 Bitstreaming   |2009-02-20 07:09:00
It will bitstream both Dolby True HD and DTS Master Audio via HDMI, it will also
decode Dolby True HD via HDMI.

It cannot decode DTS Master if sending as
PCM.

Owned one since September, current firmware is version 15.

It's been very
reliable and stable.
Tom Volotta  - High Definition Audio Formats   |2009-02-24 10:43:47
Marc M: As noted by Butch and Bob... Yes the BDP-S350 does output Dolby
TrueHD, DTS-HD High Resolution and DTS-HD Master audio formats through the
player's HDMI 1.3 connection. You may be confusing the S550's advanced feature
of being able to decode those formats to analog outputs, then sending direct to
a sound amp.

There are also limitations (in ALL players) if using either the
Coaxial or Optical digital "Bitstream" outputs. The advanced high
definition codecs are not available through these paths. Output is confined to
regular DD, DTS and 2 channel LPCM.
Tom Volotta  - Pro-Logic   |2009-02-24 11:07:47
Gerald: The S350 does have analog stereo RCA output jacks which will carry
Dolby Pro-Logic to your older Sansui. Upgrading to audio gear which can at
least delivery Dolby Digital or DTS 5.1 will enrich your Blu-ray watching
experience considerably. The surround channels are more discrete than
Pro-Logic, and the Low Frequency Effects (LFE) sound (the ".1" in 5.1,
6.1 or 7.1) makes for superior bass punctuation for movies and music. Going for
equipment that can accept HDMI 1.3 input will insure a higher quality, more
accurate sound, and depending on the specs of the gear - access to the newer HD
formats.

Don't even think about running S-Video from the BDP-S350 into your
receiver. Connect the HDMI output directly to your display.
Tom Volotta  - BDP-S350 Bitstreaming   |2009-02-24 11:19:15
Bob: The S350 does not decode Dolby TrueHD. Like Dolby Digital Plus, DTS-HD
High Resolution and DTS-HD Master, Dolby TrueHD is simply transported over the
HDMI path, where decoding takes place in a separate piece of audio equipment.
Andrew Davidson  - BDP-350 Decoding Dolby True HD   |2009-03-03 07:56:57
Tom: According to Sony's specifications, the player will decode internally
Dolby True HD to PCM, bitstreamed to the receiver/processor.
Tom Volotta  - re: BDP-350 Decodig Dolby TrueHD   |2009-03-04 13:59:34
Andrew: Decoding... I don't think so.

I do see on Sony's website under
Features for the S350 that they say the is a "Dolby TrueHD decoder
built-in," and under Specifications where it says, "Dolby TrueHD
Decoding: Yes." However, neither jives with audio output signals listed in
the Operating Instructions, the interface outputs on the back of the player or
the TrueHD spec from Dolby.

Dolby says TrueHD's 6-channel, 24-bit/192 kHz or
8-channel, 24-bit/96 kHz audio can be transported as a bitstream over HDMI 1.3
from a Blu-ray player. This is consistent with the S350's manual, which shows
7.1 channel LCPM output via HDMI. The only other way to get those eight
channels is if the player is in fact decoding TrueHD, then sending those signals
out through analog jacks. The BDP-S350 does not have those extra 8 jacks, so if
"decoding" is going on, the S350 is keeping it to itself.

Dolby TrueHD
is NOT transported over the S350's coaxial or optical audio outputs. Instead, a
legacy Dolby Digital 5.1 signal is sent to your receiver or other audio
processing gear. Dolby says a 640kbps bitstream from Blu-ray content provides
an "enhanced" audio experience.

Since the only audio outputs on the
BDP-S350 are HDMI, Coaxial and Optical digital and analog stereo, I am at a loss
as to why Sony claims Dolby TrueHD is being "decoded" to it's 6 or 8
channel variants. TrueHD is being "down-mixed" for 5.1 output via
coax/optical, and a 2-channel LPCM option is available via HDMI, coax/optical or
the stereo analog jacks when the "Audio Output Priority" and "Audio
Settings" are configured properly, but that's not "decoding."

The
Sony BDP-S550 DOES decode the new HD audio formats.

This wouldn't be the first
time specs on a website were wrong or incomplete.

Maybe I'm missing something?
Tom Volotta  - re: BDP-350 Decodig Dolby TrueHD - CONTINUED   |2009-03-04 14:04:30
Continued...

Dolby TrueHD is NOT transported over the S350's coaxial or optical
audio outputs. Instead, a legacy Dolby Digital 5.1 signal is sent to your
receiver or other audio processing gear. Dolby says a 640kbps bitstream from
Blu-ray content provides an "enhanced" audio experience.

Since the only
audio outputs on the BDP-S350 are HDMI, Coaxial and Optical digital and analog
stereo, I am at a loss as to why Sony claims Dolby TrueHD is being
"decoded" to it's 6 or 8 channel variants. TrueHD is being
"down-mixed" for 5.1 output via coax/optical, and a 2-channel LPCM
option is available via HDMI, coax/optical or the stereo analog jacks when the
"Audio Output Priority" and "Audio Settings" are configured
properly, but that's not "decoding."

This wouldn't be the first time
specs on a website were wrong or incomplete.

Maybe I'm missing something?
Tom Volotta  - Additional Decode Info   |2009-03-05 09:13:48
Here are two links to Dolby which hopefully will help clarify the TrueHD
decoding matter.

BD players:
http://www.dolby.com/consumer/technology/
trueHD/AVRs/trueHD_avrs_2.html

Connections:
http:
//www.dolby.com/consumer/technology/trueHD/avrs/tr
ueHD_avrs_3.html

Technically, the S350 is decoding the Dolby TrueHD internally,
BUT that decoding is to six or eight channel LPCM, which is output ONLY through
the HDMI 1.3 interface because the S350 does not have the eight outputs required
to send the real, decoded analog to your sound gear. So, Andrew is correct in
saying the S350 decodes to LPCM, but the fact remains that the only way those
signals can be heard is via HDMI out of the S350 to external audio equipment.
Tom Volotta  - Decode Info - Continued:   |2009-03-05 09:35:27
Continued -

In this case, maybe the manufacturers could help simplify things
by only saying the audio signal is being "decoded" when it is being
broken out to its discrete analog audio channels from the BD player. That's
what most people think of when the player spec says "decode," not
sending it as a digital bitstream to a receiver. The way the Features and
Specifications are written from player to player (e.g. Sony S350 and S550) can
also be unclear. Makes it sound like the S350 does more than it really can.


Anyway, sorry if I've contributed to the confusion.

...TV
Tom   |2009-03-16 06:56:23
I have the S350 and the STR 820 eceiver. If you set the BD player to
"direct" in the audio settings the receiver will decode Dolby True HD
and DTS HD sounds over HDMI. If you leave the setting to mixed the BD player
will decode on board and send LPCM to the receiver. This is assumes you have the
lates firmware update on the BD player.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

Manufacturer Sony
Model BDP-S350
Output Resolutions 1080p • 720p
HDMI Version 1.3
Audio Format Support DTS-HD Master Audio (Bitstream) • Dolby TrueHD (Bitstream)
Supported Media Formats BD-R • CD • DVD • DVD+R • DVD-R • BD-ROM • DVD-ROM • DVD-RW • DVD+RW
BD Profile 2.0
Recordable No





Like this article? Bookmark and share with any of the sites below.
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!StumbleUpon!Yahoo!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!


 
HDTV Guide Advert

 
  home theater news  |  equipment reviews 
  blu-ray reviews  |  dvd  |  theatrical reviews  
  music download reviews  |  music disc reviews
  contact  |  about-us  |  careers   |  brands 
  Subscribe to Us   |   RSS   |  AVRev Forums
  front page  |  virtual tours  |  dealer locator
  how to features  |   lifestyle & design articles
  Want Your Home Theater Featured on MHT?
   CE Partners: HDD  |  HDF  |  VGT  |  SD  |  DVD
   
  Click Here to Advertise with Us | Specs
  Sponsors | privacy policy | terms of use
  909 N. Sepulveda Blvd. El Segundo, CA 90245
  Ads: 310.280.4476 | Contact Us
  Content: 310.280.4575 | Mike Flacy