equipment reviews
This Month's Featured Equipment Reviews
SVS Ultra Bookshelf Loudspeaker Review
Opera Mezza Loudspeakers Review
Vanatoo Transparent One Powered Monitors Review
HiFiMan RE-400 In-Ear Monitor Review
Marantz SA-11S3 SACD Player & DAC Review
Latest AV News
Home Theater/Media Center PC Forum Topics:
Classic Media Server Reviews
Past Home Theater/Media Center PC News
 
Western Digital TV Live Hub Review   Print E-mail
Home Theater Media Servers Home Theater/Media Center PCs
Written by Mike Flacy   
Thursday, 04 November 2010
Article Index
Western Digital TV Live Hub Review  
Content and Conclusion

Content:

With the introduction of the hard drive into the mix, this allows Western Digital to open up the player to the rental market.  With Blockbuster on Demand support, you can rent newly released films and watch them with 24 hours of starting them.  Unfortunately, the dinosaur that is Blockbuster has covered all purchases in more DRM than I thought possible.  Want to watch your recently purchased legal copy of Scott Pilgrim vs. The World on another TV in the house?  Sorry!  You can't stream it to another television or computer in the house.  Thanks for not trying, Blockbuster.  It's no wonder that company is slipping into obscurity.

Similar to the last rendition of the Live player, we also have Netflix at our disposal.  The interface is similar, but it's not as sleek as the Apple TV interface for browsing Netflix.  It's also tough to find an Internet connected device that doesn't utilize Netflix these days, so interface is key in bringing people back for more.  Opposite from Apple TV, this device requires you to authorize the player as one of your Netflix devices over on the Netflix website.  Streaming performance has been improved from the previous player, possibly to caching the streaming content on the new hard drive.  It also seemed faster to get to the content I wanted in the interface, although still not beating out Apple TV.

Internet interface

Beyond Netflix and Blockbuster, you have Youtube, Pandora, Last.fm, Flickr, Live365, Accuweather and Mediafly apps at your disposal.  Beyond Pandora (and the included functionality to like to dislike songs), there really isn't much that stands out in the pack.  I also didn't care for Mediafly's interface and the convoluted navigation to try and subscribe to a podcast or other Internet content.  However, I did like the internal Facebook application.  The navigation is laid out well, perhaps even more streamlined than Facebook on the Xbox 360. It also includes the ability to upload content by connecting the camera / video camera to the Live Hub and directly uploading, pretty handy if you really aren't into spending time editing your media on a computer.

Caveats:

One of the problems I ran into with the Live Hub was trying to stream multiple HD files from different computers in the house at the same time over a wired network.  I can understand the problems with trying to stream to wireless notebooks, but not being able to do this on a wired connection seems like an unfortunate mis-step if Western Digital wants consumers to use this as their server for the entire house.  I also didn't care for the lack of functionality for transferring files via other sources like USB sticks or portable hard drives.  You have to connect via an external computer rather than WD including a file transfer tool in the UI; perhaps in a future update of the interface.  Finally, I'm still astounded that there's no built in Wi-Fi functionality at this stage in the product revision of the WD players.  It seems like an obvious inclusion at this point for those without wired connections at their home theaters.  (You can still purchase a Wi-Fi USB dongle to get access on the player, but that takes up a USB port and is an extra cost.)

Top view
Conclusion:

The Western Digital Live Hub is one of the most fully featured media players I've tested  in a while, something that may not bode well for the upcoming release of the Boxee Box later this month.  While they really need to find a better partner for their downloadable DRM filled media, the player is a powerhouse when it comes to storing, cataloguing and playing an enormous variety of file formats.  Also, this is the most user friendly revision of the user interface to date.  If you are looking for a more robust platform to consumer digital media on within your home or even just your home theater, don't hesitate to consider the Western Digital Live Hub as your primary media player. (MSRP: $199.99)  Highly recommended!
   Comments
Add New | Search
  
GLEN LESLIE  - OWNER/DESIGNER/INSTALLER/PROGRAMMER   |2010-11-12 06:26:38
FINALLY, A PIECE THAT HAS COMPONENT AND COMPOSITE AND DIGITAL AND GIVES YOU
WRETCHED HDMI WITHOUT IMPUNING COMPONENT.

THE ISSUE I HAVE WITH YOU IS THAT
YOU ARE LIKE ALL GEN "Y" PEOPLE. YOU WANT MULTIPLE EVERYTHING FROM A
CHEAP BOX AND FORGET WHAT A WHOLEHOUSE SYSTEM IS FOR AND WHY WE INSTALL
THEM.

YOU WORRY ABOUT IT HAVING A HARD DRIVE IN IT [THAT WILL BREAK IN TIME]
AND NOT ABOUT THE BIGGER PICTURE, STREAMING FROM YOUR HOME NAS. BUT THAT WOULD
BE BECAUSE YOU ARE CHEAP AND DON'T HAVE A NAS AND WANT TO SHARE WITH EVERY
COMPUTER IN THE HOUSE.

THERE'S A RIGHT WAY TO DO IT AND THERE'S THE BAND AID
WAY TO DO IT.

YOU MAKE NO MENTION OF RUNNING THIS VIA EITHERNET BROWSER. IS
THERE ONE? CAN WE USE IP TO RUN THIS FROM TOUCHSCREENS OR IPADS OR CELL PHONES
WITH APPS?

NO MENTION OF OVERALL CONTENT COMPARED TO SAY, ROKU. DO THEY HAVE
45 OR 50 APPS THAT YOU CAN CHOOSE FROM AND IS THERE FREE CONTENT ON ANY OF THESE
APPS?

THEY UPGRADE THEIR SOFTWARE ALL THE TIME, THIS LEADS ME TO BELIEVE THAT
THEY EITHER JUST FIGURED OUT WHAT THEY'RE DOING AND WOE BE THOSE THAT HAVE
SUFFERED TRYING TO USE THIS SINCE IT CAME OUT OR ELSE; THEY ARE TRYING TO BE
INNOVATORS AND LEAD THE PACK WITH DESIGN, BUT YOU MAKE IT SOUND LIKE THEY ARE
TRYING TO CATCH UP INSTEAD.

BASED ON YOUR REVIEW, I WOULD PICK ROKU OVER THIS
AS YOU SUPPLY TOO MANY NEGATIVES AND UNANSWERED QUESTIONS.

ROKU IS ROCK
SOLID, EVEN IF THEY MADE A MISTAKE TRYING TO BE LIKE APPLE BY BUILDING A
MINISCULE SIZED BOX AND MAKING COMPONENT AN ALSO RAN.

THERE ARE A TON OF
PEOPLE THAT OWN FLATSCREENS WITHOUT HDMI AND A BUNCH FURTHER THAT OWN TV SETS
WITH HDMI 1.0 OR 1.1 THAT WOULD HAVE ISSUES IF THEY TRIED TO USE HDMI THRU A
THEATER RECEIVER; SO YOU DON'T ADDRESS WHAT YOU USED FOR PICTURE OTHER THAN THE
PICTURE WAS GREAT.

TRY USING A FIVE YEAR OLD TV SET LIKE MOST OF AMERICA HAS
AND SEE HOW IT RUNS.
TRY THE COMPONET VIDEO ON 720P AND TELL ME IF IT'S BETTER
OR DIFFERENT FROM HDMI.

THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT DON'T LIKE HOW 1080P
LOOKS COMPARED TO 720P FROM COMPONENT. YOU COULD LIKEN IT TO TUBES VERSUS SOLID
STATE; THEY BOTH MAKE MUSIC, BUT DON'T SOUND THE SAME.

SO IT IS WITH HDMI FOR
A LOT OF PEOPLE, ONCE A REAL INSTALLER LET'S THEM COMPARE THE TWO.

DO YOU SEE
ANYONE COMPARING HDMI TO COMPONENT AT BEST BUY?

THIS IS A LEGITIMATE QUESTION
BECAUSE OF HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE A NEW HDMI VERSION 1.3 OR 1.4 TV SET AND USE
ONLY HDMI.

THEN TAKE AWAY FROM THAT NUMBER, HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE A SET THAT
IS CONNECTED USING HDMI AND IT DOES 1.4 AND THEY ARE CONNECTED TO A CABLE BOX
WITH VERSION [I DON'T KNOW] AND THE PICTURE IS ONLY 1080i.

DON'T BE CONFUSED
BY THE NUMBERS THAT LIE.

THEY CLAIM WHAT PERCENTAGE OF HOUSEHOLDS HAVE HDTV
AND ARE CORRECT BASED ON SALES;

BUT LOOK FURTHER INTO THIS:
HOW MANY HOMES
Bob Smoot   |2010-11-30 20:23:10
@Glen Leslie: Stop yelling. No one wants to read all caps.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."






Like this article? Bookmark and share with any of the sites below.
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!StumbleUpon!Yahoo!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!


 

 
  home theater news  |  equipment reviews 
  blu-ray reviews  |  dvd  |  theatrical reviews  
  music download reviews  |  music disc reviews
  contact  |  about-us  |  careers   |  brands 
  Subscribe to Us   |   RSS   |  AVRev Forums
  front page  |  virtual tours  |  dealer locator
  how to features  |   lifestyle & design articles
  Want Your Home Theater Featured on MHT?
   CE Partners: HDD  |  HDF  |  VGT  |  SD  |  DVD
   
  Click Here to Advertise with Us | Specs
  Sponsors | privacy policy | terms of use
  909 N. Sepulveda Blvd. El Segundo, CA 90245
  Ads: 310.280.4476 | Contact Us
  Content: 310.280.4575 | Mike Flacy