| Channel Islands Audio VDA-2 DAC Review |
|
|
| Home Theater Accessories Acoustics, EQ & Room Tuning | ||||
| Written by Andre Marc | ||||
| Wednesday, 29 September 2010 | ||||
Page 1 of 2
Channel Islands Audio (CIA), has been around for a number of years producing high value, versatile audio components and accessories. Their Class D switching amplifiers have gotten rave reviews for their small footprint, efficiency, and sound quality. CIA also makes passive preamps, power filters, and upgrades to other manufactures products, like the Logitech Squeezebox and Wadia iTransport (and Squeezebox Duet) power supplies, which by all accounts, dramatically improve the performance of both. ![]() The VDA-2 DAC was designed with the notion that simpler is better. According to CIA, “traditional DAC designs use brick-wall digital filters, usually followed by more analog filtering to reduce sampling noise, but cause signal degradation in the process. Another approach has been to use no filtering at all, but this adds noise to the analog signal. Both of these designs have their strengths and weaknesses, but neither tends to be a good trade-off. Our design uses only a mild "slow roll-off" digital filter and first order analog filter to tame the sampling noise. This architecture has reduced filtering artifacts compared to brick-wall types, and lower sampling noise than filterless types, resulting in a more "analog" sound. “ The VDA-2 accepts TOSlink and Coaxial S/PDIF digital inputs. The signal is then fed to the CS8416 24 bit/192k low jitter input receiver, then to the Burr Brown PCM1794 balanced/current output DAC. According to CIA, “our unique output stage is a fully discrete/zero feedback design and uses only a single transistor per output to insure the purity of the audio signal. Circuit board is high quality gold-plated 2 oz. copper with lead-free silver solder construction. “ The output arrangement allows for 2 pair of single-ended connections, for connection to two separate systems or recording devices, or a single pair of balanced outputs (with the optional VRX•1 cable pair). The external 14vAC power wal wart supply is included as a standard accessory. Set Up and Listening: ![]() Working from memory, comparing the VDA-2 to the Benchmark DAC1 HDR, I think the CIA had a bit more flesh on the bone, and a more analog sound, where as the Benchmark presented things a few rows back, but maybe with the slightest bit more focus. I don't know which was more accurate, but both are superbly engineered and snag free products, so it will be a matter of taste. I was leaning towards the CIA. I also fed the VDA-2 a signal from my Marantz 5003 CD player and it was a tougher call. The 5003 uses an excellent internal DAC chip and it has trickle down technology from the much more expensive Marantz players in the line. The signal fed through the CIA had a bit more midrange clarity, but I am talking just a bit more. |
||||







