Audio Video Revolution Forum

Audio Video Revolution Forum (
-   Blu-ray Software (
-   -   A re-examining of the PS3 (

TheMoose 06-08-2008 07:42 PM

A re-examining of the PS3 takes a fresh look at the PS3

From Ars Technica,

They say it got smart: a 2008 review of the PS3

The revolution will not be televised, it will be downloaded an update at a time

Back in the crazy days before the current generation of gaming consoles, the console you bought at retail was the console you had for the life of the hardware. My SNES acts exactly the same now as it did when it was first released, and outside of the addition of Xbox Live, the first Xbox system remained largely unchanged throughout the hardware's life cycle. Those days are long over, and now which version of Sony's PlayStation 3 that you bought is only one part of the equation: welcome to the firmware wars.

The firmware has received update after update. The Blu-ray capability has become much stronger, and it may in fact be the most affordable and fully-featured high definition disc player on the market. The price has come down to a much more palatable $400 for the 40GB model, and the game selection continues to improve, with strong multiplatform support and a wide selection of exclusive games

Sony has already launched the software update that allows the PS3 to play discs that use the 2.0 profile, called "BD Live," and at the moment the PS3 is one of the few players that will be able to play these discs. What does BD Live get you? Picture in picture, online features like trivia games, and other goodies like downloadable ring tones. The price of standalone players that are fully compliant with the 2.0 spec will most likely be above the $400 asking price of the PS3. Furthermore, buying Sony's console instead of a standalone player also gives you an added insurance policy: with its media processing muscle, hard drive, and Ethernet port, the PS3 is one of the only completely future-proof Blu-ray players on the market. No matter how the spec changes, the PS3 will be able to play it.

The Blu-ray and DivX situation has left Sony with the upper hand over Microsoft in the race to turn consoles into networked home media players. In short, Sony's gaming system is one of the most robust and affordable pieces of home theater hardware on the market: it's the best Blu-ray player, it has a relatively low price, it's fully Divx compatible, and it allows video streaming from your network. Furthermore, regular DVDs look amazing after being upscaled, and the system now takes advantage of all your high-end audio equipment. If you take away the gaming features completely, the hardware is still worth more than $400 for home theater enthusiasts; in a surreal twist, you could argue that Blu-ray is the Trojan horse bringing PS3 gaming to the masses, not the other way around.

The Good

* The best Blu-ray player on the market
* Rock solid hardware with a minimal defect rate
* Excellent media functions across the board
* Dual Shock 3 is a great controller, with many options for creative developers
* Online store has no upper limit on size of games
* Storage is a snap to upgrade
* Excellent convergence with the PlayStation Portable
* An ever-increasing library of exclusives
* Home could make great strides in online gaming

The Bad

* Home has seen too many delays
* Online play still doesn't measure up to Xbox
* Backwards compatibility seems to be going the way of the dodo in newer models
* Focus on media could take away from gaming aspects of the system

The Ugly

* Don't think that numerical scores are coming back, but since we're re-rating the hardware, I thought we'd take them out for one last hurrah, since these days the PS3 gets a...

These are just snippets from a 5 page story, you can read the whole story by clicking the link at the top.
Going from a 6 at release to a 9 today just shows how much the PS3 has improved & it continues to evolve with each firmware update.

Don't think Joe 6 Pack hasn't noticed, my 70 year old Dad just asked for a PS3 for Fathers day, this is huge as the only thing he knows about this stuff is what he sees at my house & from the old gear I give them when I upgrade.

I've already picked him a 40G up & am downloading game demos now & I'll be setting up a WiFi at their house.

kennyt 06-09-2008 04:48 PM

Re: A re-examining of the PS3
I still don't think it's that good a Blu-ray player, but I must agree, it is the most up to date, ironic that it was one of the first made eh? I do like having one for the games, I just wish GTA IV was in 1080p...

The Kipnis Studios 06-09-2008 09:04 PM

Re: A re-examining of the PS3
So how can it be that the single best triple processor computer (short of the Apple Dual Quad Core) can be anything less (digitally connected) than the very best stand alone BluRay player?

Sure things change technologically, but the PS3 was designed to handle upgrades to the format, up to 1920 x 1080p. How can this platform perform worse (in digital) than a stand alone BD player, even the most recent?

kennyt 06-10-2008 03:29 AM

Re: A re-examining of the PS3

Put one in your system and A-B it to the stand alone players, I just re-did this test with mine (an 80 G model with v2.35 firmware) to my Sony BDP-S1, both using identical HDMI cables, the PS3 has weak edge detail and color saturation compared to the Sony BDP-S1, and this is Sony's FIRST Blu-ray player, I can't imagine how the 2000ES compares to it.

Yes, it has super fast load times and is capable of profile 2.0, but the remote is blue tooth, so a total PITA for universal remote users as none can be programmed to control it, IR/Blue tooth relayers are around but I haven't tried on yet to comment on them.

Even via HDMI I do not find the audio as good, it seems to lack bass definition and control, and while it will output DTS HD MA, it will only do so in MC PCM, I want it to do bitstream.... OK, minor gripe, but I had to air it!

Robinson_A 06-10-2008 12:36 PM

Re: A re-examining of the PS3
While I love the PS3 as a Blu-ray player I must agree with Ken that the BDP-S1 is a far better player. However, I have had trouble in the past and still to this day upgrading the BDP-S1 firmware where the PS3 has been flawless in that regard. For day to day livability the PS3 has all other Blu-ray players licked but as far as a performance juggernaut the PS3 is not. I'm going to try and update my other Blu-ray players this week to see if the process isn't a bit smoother now. Meanwhile my PS3s continue to be my players of choice at the moment.

kennyt 06-10-2008 02:22 PM

Re: A re-examining of the PS3
Yeah, I love the way you can use flash drives to update the PS3 too, nice touch to save you from burning discs!

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:13 AM.

1996-2008 | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Terms of Use

SEO by vBSEO 3.6.1