Blu-ray reviews
This Month's Featured Equipment Reviews
Merrill Audio THOR Mono Block Amplifiers Review
Plinius Hautonga Integrated Amplifier Review
KEF R700 Loudspeaker Review
Marantz SA-14S1 SACD Player & DSD DAC Review
Genesis G7c Loudspeakers
10 Most Recent Blu-ray Reviews
Latest AV News
Blu-ray Software Forum Topics:
Most Popular Blu-ray Reviews
Past Blu-ray Software News
 
I, Robot  Print E-mail
Blu-ray Sci-Fi-Fantasy
Written by Bill Warren   
Thursday, 01 May 2008

2 of 3 people found the following review helpful

Overall rating (weighted)
4.1
Movie Rating:
3.5
Audio Quality:
4.0
Video Quality:
4.5
Supplements:
4.0
Purchase: Buy from Amazon.com
Was this review helpful to you? yes     no
This is not based on Isaac Asimov’s well-known collection of short stories of the same title; as the credits say, it’s only “suggested” by the famous book.  The movie does use his famous “Three Laws of Robotics” and generally treats them with respect; a couple of characters come from Asimov, too, notably Dr. Susan Calvin, here played somewhat stiffly by Bridget Moynahan, much younger than Calvin was in most of the stories.  The movie is reasonably entertaining and spectacularly well produced.

The script was originally titled “Hardwired” and had nothing to do with Asimov.  When Alex Proyas, a long-time science fiction reader, was hired to direct, he had rewrites done that incorporated Asimov’s ideas.  The story is credited to Jeff Vintar (who wrote “Hardwired”); he also cowrote “Final Fantasy” and is adapting Asimov’s “Foundation” books to the screen.  The co-writer of the final script is Akiva Goldsman, who’s had an erratic career: he wrote “A Beautiful Mind” but also “Batman Forever.”

As a murder mystery, it’s hit-and-miss.  Some clues are planted very cleverly; others are treated so ineptly that it’s obvious that someone knows and cares little about mystery story logic.  For example, police detective Del Spooner (Will Smith) gets an important clue by accident, when his grandmother (Adrian L. Ricard) happens to say something that causes the “That’s it!  Now I know!” reaction common in scripts written by someone who knows little about mystery story structure, and doesn’t care enough to learn.

Technically, the film is dazzling.  There are streets scenes full of people and robots, all going about their business, and the robots look precisely as real as the people do.  Daytime cityscapes—the setting is Chicago in 2035—look a bit manufactured, but the movie features the first nighttime aerial view of a futuristic city that looks exactly like similar real-life shots.  There are several major action set pieces, done spectacularly well—but the movie works better as a story than as an action showcase.

It has its problems.  Partly because Will Smith has the role, detective hero Del Spooner acts like the rules-breaking, risk-taking, wise-cracking heroes common—all too common—to cop movies of the last 20 years or so.  Actually, Spooner is somewhat different, but it’s hard to see—Will Smith kind of gets in the way.  However, Smith is very good in the role, finding shades and ideas within the character that bring Del to life.

The movie opens with Smith asleep, in mid-nightmare: he’s recalling a near-death experience (we later learn it was recent) in which he’s rescued from a submerged car by a diligent robot.  But he hates robots; he’s notorious for it at the station house, and the butt of a lot of jokes.  After all, there are millions of robots, all functioning safely because their positronic brains (an Asimov term) are coded with the unbreakable Three Laws of Robotics:
1. A robot may not injure a human being, or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm. 
2. A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law. 
3.  A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.     

Many of Asimov’s robot stories dealt with a robot that seems to have violated one of the laws; the stories were worked out carefully to show the laws were not violated.  Something like that goes on here, too, though we’re told near the end that no matter what we’ve seen happening, the Three Laws are “perfect.”  But the movie centers on artificial intelligences, supposedly Three Laws Safe, that vigorously violate the crucial First Law. 

Dr. Alfred Lanning (James Cromwell), the creator of the technology that has led to the proliferation of human-assisting robots, has just been found dead.  He fell to his death in the very high atrium lobby of U.S. Robotics’ towering office building.  A hologram of Lanning specifically summoned Del; we learn there was a connection between the two, but until much later in the film, not what the connection was.  Lawrence Robertson (Bruce Greenwood), the head of U.S. Robotics, is certain the death was a suicide, and wants it cleared up quickly.  The firm is about to release thousands of their latest model, the NS-5 Automated Domestic Assistant.  Soon there will be one robot for every five people on Earth.

Del also meets Susan Calvin, a frosty robot psychiatrist who’s also convinced—as is everyone but Del—that it’s impossible for a robot to have killed Lanning.  (Calvin and Lanning both originated in Asimov’s stories.)  Unfortunately, the script veers off into “cute” dialogue between the two; the actors handle it well, but it’s too familiar.

In Lanning’s lab, high up in the tower, they find evidence that the scientist (seen in video footage) had been working on a secret project.  Calvin tells him about V.I.K.I., a vast computer that assisted in the design of the robots, and which operates the entire U.S. Robots building.  Suddenly a robot bursts from hiding, grabs Del’s gun and leaps out the window; he cracks the pavement when he hits, but is unharmed, and runs away.

Eventually, the robot is taken into custody; though it is one of the NS-5 models, it is unlike any other robot.  It refers to Lanning as “father,” and talks about its dreams—and seems to have emotions.  It calls itself Sonny.  (Actor Alan Tudyk provided the movement source and voice for Sonny.)   Much to his quiet surprise, Del finds himself drawn to the friendly, soft-spoken robot, and begins to think it—no, he—may not have killed Lanning.  Which leaves the question of just who did.

When Del visits Lanning’s mansion—interestingly, it’s in an old style with lots of wood—a demolition robot scheduled to tear the place down in the morning is suddenly activated and begins smashing the building as Del hastens to get away.  (Carrying Lanning’s lonely cat.)  This is fast-paced and visually stunning.  Later, there’s another big fight between Del and dozens of robots as they plummet through a downtown tunnel.  The robots leap from giant cargo trucks, and the story heads for showdown.  When you think it’s over, it starts up again.

The climax takes place at the very top of U.S. Robots’ atrium lobby; Proyas engages in showy camera movements, with the camera doing 360-pans over and under the web-like catwalks.  It’s dazzling, exciting, and always clear about who’s doing what to whom and where.  He occasionally uses camera movements to reveal unexpected details, as in the first scene at the U.S. Robots building.  The high definition image on this Blu-ray DVD renders these details near-flawlessly.

“I, Robot” is well-paced, moving along at a good clip until the three-quarter mark, where it bogs down somewhat.  It’s also a little confusing; it took me a day or so to figure the relationship of the secret of the whole thing to the Three Laws.  It also looks terrific, with its cityscapes featuring fast-moving cars and trucks on giant expressways and tunnels.  But this city also has a slum area, with older buildings and seedy businesses—but also lots of robots.

The cinematography is by Simon Duggan (who worked with Proyas on “Garage Days” in their native Australia), the visual effects were supervised by John Nelson, and the production designer was the busy Patrick Tatopoulos.  Proyas also directed “The Crow” and “Dark City.”

The movie’s weaknesses and strengths seem to alternate.  Sometimes the mystery elements are well handled, at other times they’re clumsy and trite.  The dialogue varies as well; sometimes it’s pretty good (“You’re the dumbest smart person I ever met”), sometimes it’s obvious and familiar.  Yes, Smith sometimes yells wisecracks in action scenes, but Proyas wisely soft-pedals this. 

One of the basic problems with tackling Asimov’s Three Laws in movie form is that there have been so many robots in movies and on TV that have gone berserk that it’s difficult to accept the infallibility of the Laws.  Even the ads for “I, Robot” say “some laws were made to be broken.”  But Asimov stuck to his guns.  It’s not easy to tell here if the Three Laws are bent or broken.  But they’re not firmly adhered to.  A recorded Lanning image declares the Three Laws dictate that “the created must protect the creator, even when it is against the creator’s will.”  But Asimov’s careful wording of the Three Laws avoided that.  It says that a robot must not injure a human being; it does not say that a robot must protect the human race.

Smith and Moynahan are both good, though she’s stiff, as is Adrian L. Ricard as Smith’s devoted, salty grandmother.  James Cromwell is especially impressive; it’s rare to see a scientist depicted in such a convincing manner—he actually talks like one.  But Bruce Greenwood, as the shifty executive, can’t make a mark with his too-familiar role, and Chi McBride is much too familiar as Del’s boss. 

The extra materials are frustratingly elusive, at least on my equipment.  There’s a list of the extras on the box, but I could access them only during the movie by pressing one of those colored buttons on the remote.  Doing this gives a scene-specific list of extras available—behind-the-scenes shots, details of the special effects, info about Asimov and his stories and so forth.  The box roster includes deleted scenes, but I didn’t see them; perhaps they can be invoked from specific scenes, but I was unable to locate an accessible list of the extras.  From what I did see, they’re respectable and interesting.  The commentary track by director Proyas and co-writer Jeff Vintar (not Akiva “Goldsmith” as the box list has it) is moderately interesting.  There are several others, including one devoted to the score, but I didn’t listen to them.  Perhaps the extras are accessible by using the remote, but I wasn’t able to deduce a way to do this.

On the commentary track, Proyas claims that he wanted to make The Definitive Robot Movie, but he didn’t accomplish that.  “I, Robot” is not all we could hope for from a movie related, at least, to Asimov’s story; it’s basically a big summer action movie.  But it’s mostly very smart both in its science fictional details and in the overall plot.  It seems a bit strange to see an action movie in which the action scenes—all too often the only thing such movies have to offer—are secondary to what’s otherwise going on.  The movie is compromised, but like the Three Laws, it’s not destroyed.  It’s a summer action movie with something on its mind.
Studio 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment
MPAA Rating PG-13
Starring Will Smith, Bridget Moynahan, Alan Tudyk, James Cromwell, Bruce Greenwood, Adrian L. Ricard, Chi McBride, Jerry Wasserman, Fiona Hogan
Director Alex Proyas
Film Release Year 2004
Release Year 2008
Resolution(s) 1080p (main feature) • 1080p (supplements)
Aspect Ratio 2.35:1
Running Time 1 hr. 54 mins.
Sound Formats English DTS-HD Master 5.1 • French Dolby Digital 5.1 • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1
Subtitles Cantonese • English • Korean • Spanish
Special Features Behind the Camera; Day Out of Days production diaries; CGI and design featurettes; Deleted scenes and alternate ending; Commentary track by director Alex Proyas and screenwriter Jeff Vintar (box says Akiva "Goldsmith"); there are other commentary tracks, too; Trivia track. These seem to be accessible only from within the movie, and none of the featurettes run full-length.
Forum Link http://www.avrevforum.com
Reviewer Bill Warren







Like this article? Bookmark and share with any of the sites below.
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!StumbleUpon!Yahoo!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
 
HDTV Guide Advert

 
  home theater news  |  equipment reviews 
  blu-ray reviews  |  dvd  |  theatrical reviews  
  music download reviews  |  music disc reviews
  contact  |  about-us  |  careers   |  brands 
  Subscribe to Us   |   RSS   |  AVRev Forums
  front page  |  virtual tours  |  dealer locator
  how to features  |   lifestyle & design articles
  Want Your Home Theater Featured on MHT?
   CE Partners: HDD  |  HDF  |  VGT  |  SD  |  DVD
   
  Click Here to Advertise with Us | Specs
  Sponsors | privacy policy | terms of use
  909 N. Sepulveda Blvd. El Segundo, CA 90245
  Ads: 310.280.4476 | Contact Us
  Content: 310.280.4575 | Mike Flacy