Blu-ray reviews
This Month's Featured Equipment Reviews
Tisbury Audio Mini Passive Review
Denon AVR-S700W& Envaya Bluetooth Speaker Reviews
CLONES Audio 25p Power Amplifier Review
Audioengine A2+ Desktop Speakers Review
Darwin Truth Silver Cable Review
10 Most Recent Blu-ray Reviews
Latest AV News
Blu-ray Software Forum Topics:
Most Popular Blu-ray Reviews
Past Blu-ray Software News
 
Stranger Than Fiction (Special Edition)  Print E-mail
Blu-ray Comedy
Written by Bill Warren & AVRev.com   
Friday, 21 November 2008

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Overall rating (weighted)
3.9
Movie Rating:
4.0
Audio Quality:
4.0
Video Quality:
4.0
Supplements:
3.0
Purchase: Buy from Amazon.com
Was this review helpful to you? yes     no
Even though it stars Will Ferrell, “Stranger Than Fiction” is a quiet, understated movie with a detailed treatment of characters—each is shown to have many levels—that’s just about impossible to classify. It’s funny but not really a comedy, serious but not really a drama, includes an utterly fantastic element but is otherwise realistic. It’s the first filmed script by Zach Helm; based on this, he’s a major find, a more realistic—if that’s the word—variation on Charlie Kaufman.

Ferrell’s performance is not quite like anything he’s done before; he’s a regular guy, nice enough but withdrawn from the world, shielded behind a wall of slowly-built but now near-impervious routine. Ferell does not play Harold Crick for overt comedy, he’s not trying to elicit laughter. Harold is just a guy.

He’s so caught up in routine, mathematics, charts, and everything being just so that director Marc Forster (“Finding Neverland”) has the graphs, charts, lists and other defining elements of Harold’s life literally depicted on screen, in animated, narrow white lines that clearly depict the fussy parameters of Harold’s self-restricted life.

He can immediately multiply two long numbers, he takes 4.7 minute coffee breaks and lunches just as proscribed. His favorite word is “integer,” and he is, not surprisingly, an IRS auditor.

We see him move through a typical day, never deviating from this narrow path which, somehow, gives him comfort because it gives him control, or at least the illusion of it. One morning as he’s brushing his teeth—always 78 strokes—he hears a woman’s voice, describing what he’s doing. Naturally, he’s nonplused, but not quite enough to alter his routine. But as he goes about his daily activities, his stride is thrown off as the narration continues (and the little animated lines fall to the pavement in thin clatters). No one else can hear it, and it does come and go—that is, it doesn’t describe everything he does.

He decides to continue his work. He visits Ana Pascal (Maggie Gyllenhaal) at her bakery shop; she refused to pay the 22 percent of her taxes that would go to national defense. Harold tries to explain everything logically, but she’s not working from logic - and Harold just can’t understand this.

Meanwhile, we also see a woman going to work, a father bidding goodbye to his young boy, who rides his bicycle around downtown Chicago streets with just a bit too much abandon. And we meet neurotic Kay Eiffel (Emma Thompson), an author who lives in an amazingly austere apartment—no decorations, no comfy chairs, all white. She has a white Selectric on a white table—and we see she is typing the very words that Harold is hearing. When efficient Penny Escher (Queen Latifah) arrives at Kay’s apartment, she reveals she’s been sent by Kay’s publisher to try to help her get over her writer’s block—she’s a famous author, but hasn’t turned in a book for ten years.

Meanwhile, Harold tries to defeat, or something, the ongoing narration by narrating his life himself, but that doesn’t accomplish anything but some puzzled looks from passersby. He sees a useless shrink (an utterly unrecognizable Tom Hulce) at his office, but finally winds up consulting with a literature theorist and college professor, Jules Hilbert (Dustin Hoffman). Hilbert is somewhat interested in Harold’s case but, not unreasonably, assumes he’s nuts. But he throws himself into the task, first ascertaining that Harold doesn’t imagine himself to be a famous literary character in a published book—he’s not Frankenstein’s Monster, Miss Marple or the Golem, for instance.

Then Kay types that Harold will soon die. This is, not surprisingly, a shock to Harold. Hilbert says that if Harold’s book is a comedy, “you get hitched;” if it’s a tragedy, “you die.” He suggests that a lot of romances begin with the two central characters hating each other, so Harold begins trying to get close to Ana. At first, she’s not interested, but his bland earnestness starts to win her over.

In Hilbert’s office, Harold sees Kay on a TV show, taped ten years before, and recognizes her voice as his narrator’s. Too bad, says Hilbert; Kay, whom he hasn’t met, is a great writer, but in all the novels she’s written so far, her central characters die—just as they learn the meaning of life. So now Harold has to get Ana to love him, and he has to actually meet Kay Eiffel, who lives right there in Chicago.

“Stranger Than Fiction” is a very delicate movie, so much so that some may find it a bit boring, but I was deeply engrossed in the characters, all of whom are richly realized. Kay Eiffel may be a bit TOO richly realized—she’s wildly eccentric, putting out half-smoked cigarettes in tissues she’s spat into, then leaving the sodden lumps all over the place. She’s given to standing at the edge of the roof of her building, imagining plunging to her death. She also imagines swerving her car to miss a little boy on a bicycle and plunging into the river, again to her death. She is, in fact, entirely too focused on death. Although her boundaries are different and come from different impulses and mental tics, she’s as bound by her surroundings as was Harold—whom she is now allowing, in her novel, to emerge from his shell. (The movie dodges the obvious question of whether Kay’s novel is about a man who hears his life being narrated; I suspect the filmmakers felt that would fold the movie in on itself. But I’ll bet Charlie Kaufman would have tackled the idea.)

There’s something winsome about Will Ferrell’s performance; he’s never been this quietly ingratiating—heck, he’s never been this QUIET. As he follows Hilbert’s advice (sometimes quite literally) to just go ahead and live his life, stop allowing all those parameters to control him, Harold—and Ferrell—loosen up. He sees a Monty Python movie, and laughs; he buys a beat-up old electric guitar and tries to learn to play it; he brings Ana flours—that is, a set of different cooking flours—and slowly but surely, charms not only her, but himself.

Just as Ferrell is winsome, Gyllenhaal is elfin - but she’s a tough, streetwise elf, pretty angry at being audited to begin with, but as Harold goes over her receipts and invoices for the last several years one evening, she makes him some chocolate chip cookies. He never eats cookies, he says, because those his mother bought at the supermarket weren’t good. (It’s clear he really thinks he’s not entitled to cookies.) But Ana is wise enough to know that Harold needs the sublime pleasure of dunking a warm chocolate chip cookie in cool milk and eating it. It doesn’t work its magic immediately; Harold stays home for a while, obsessively watching very violent TV nature shows, with cute little fuzzy animals being killed by a big sharp-toothed animals left and right. He’s jolted out of this when a big wrecking claw suddenly eats his front room; a demolition team got the wrong address. (This is a witty and big-scale echo of the violent nature shows.) But it forces Harold to temporarily abandon his apartment and, for the first time in years, live with another person, a coworker from the IRS who’s even odder than Harold.

The movie comes out foursquare for simple, accessible pleasures, including love. (At the very end, it seems that perhaps this might even occur between Professor Hilbert and Kay Eiffel. And those people, like the kid on the bike, that we see from time to time also have their own endings.)

The movie is extremely rich in themes and subtexts; the script is as intelligently written as anything coming out of Hollywood in recent memory. It’s a little slow-paced, but that’s okay; it gives us time to savor the ideas and the likeable characters. It’s also about the process of writing, and what an author owes himself (or herself), and what is owed the reader. There are interesting recurring elements, such as busses. There’s a scene on a bus between Ana and Harold, made amusingly disorienting by their being seated on either side of the big rubber seam of a long city bus that flexes in the middle. This is a completely new idea, but Forster handles it like the pro he is.

The cast performs likewise. Hoffman also played a supporting role in Forster’s “Finding Neverland;” he was very good there, and he’s very good here, a breezy, intelligent man who’s sympathetic to Harold, but also just a bit too much in love with literature. Queen Latifah has a strong presence, as usual, but her job here is to be a sounding board for Kay Eiffel. Emma Thompson is sometimes just a bit too broad, but she gathers up the frayed edges of her performance by the end of the movie.

Maggie Gyllenhaal is perfectly cast as the dedicated baker who first set out to be a lawyer - she even went to Harvard law school, a background that flips Harold’s initial perceptions of her. She’s believably angry at Harold, and yet even from the beginning we can see her inquisitive fondness for him. Gyllenhaal is one of those rare actresses who look like a leading lady and perform like character actors.

The score consists of unusual already-recorded selections, plus new music by Britt Daniel and Brian Reitzell, and it’s all superb. The score is often eccentric, with somewhat jaunty music under serious scenes and vice versa; it’s so fluid and beautifully handled that it almost seems alive, or as if the movie was created to this music. It’s one of the best scores of the year so far.

The one probably unavoidable weakness is that we’re so accustomed to movies that are narrated it’s possible to occasionally forget that the character on screen, Harold, is hearing the narration just like we are - particularly after he becomes used to it, and so usually pays it little attention.

[Written by AVRev] [START]
In terms of video, this is a one of only a few MPEG-2 encoded Blu-ray releases.  Regardless, the transfer is solid.  This transfer looks to be the same as the original release of the film on Blu-ray.  The movie is presented on a BD-50 disc so there are no compression artifacts.  There is also no edge enhancement.  However, the film has been digital processed, making the characters appear unnatural.  Many of the issue I have with the video presentation border between a transfer issue and a stylistic choice.  The colors are desaturated and the contrast overblown.  The black levels are accurate, and dark scenes having a resulting warm presentation.  Details are strong, with rich textures.  While there is some digital processing, there are no annoying edge enhancements.

The original release of "Stranger Than Fiction" on Blu-ray contained an Uncompressed PCM audio track.  This edition has opted to include a Dolby TrueHD track instead.  The audio track does not contain much in the way of sound design.  Anyone that claims to hear a difference between the original PCM track and this TrueHD presentation is pulling your leg.  Comparing the audio signals of the PCM and TrueHD track with a frequency analyzer, they are identical.  The film primarily consists of dialogue.  Every word is clear and balanced.  The music score is bled into the surrounds, but that is about all that is present in the rear channels.  The LFE channel is present, but hardly noticeable.  The balance between music and dialogue is appropriate.  All in all, a solid audio track for not much demand.

This is the second release of "Stranger Than Fiction" on the Blu-ray format.  Sony has felt compelled to release a Special Edition, which offers us some new audio commentaries and extended deleted scenes and that's all.

There are now two audio commentaries present on the Blu-ray disc.  The first commentary is with director Marc Forster and actors Will Ferrell and Dustin Hoffman.  Hoffman is the most engaging character on the track.  Everyone on the track tends to ramble about onto tangents.  The second commentary is with director Marc Forster, production designer Kevin Thompson, visual effects designer Kevin Tod Haug, director of photography Roberto Schaefer and producer Lindsay Duran.  This track contains a wealth of technical information that may or may not interest most people.

There are a variety of featurettes present on the disc, all ported over from the original release.  "Actors in Search of a Story" covers the casting of the film and the characters.  "Building the Team" focuses on the script and pre-production process.  "On Location in Chicago" takes a look at the on location shooting process.  "On the Set" is a short montage.  "Words on a Page" is an insightful featurette covering the script.  And finally, "Picture a Number: The Evolution of a G.U.I" focuses on the visual design of the film.

This release of the film on Blu-ray contains some of the previous deleted scenes as well as never before seen scenes.  There are now nine scenes instead of two.  The scenes are funny, but hardly useful in terms of narrative.  Lastly, there are a couple of theatrical trailers, neither one of "Strainger Than Fiction."

The disc is also BD-Live enabled, however, nothing is present at this point in time.

"Stranger Than Fiction" is one of those remarkably original films.  The video and audio will suffice, despite its MPEG-2 encode.  The special edition only contains a couple of extra bonus features.  So, if you already own the previous release then you probably won't need this release, unless you are a die-hard fan of the film or Will Ferrell. [END]
Studio Sony Pictures Home Entertainment
MPAA Rating PG-13
Starring Will Ferrell, Emma Thompson, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Dustin Hoffman, Queen Latifah, Tony Hale, Denise Hughes, Ricky Adams, Christian Stolte, Tom Hulce
Director Marc Forster
Film Release Year 2006
Release Year 2008
Resolution(s) 1080p (main feature) • 1080i (supplements) • 480i (supplements)
Aspect Ratio 1.85:1
Running Time 1 hr. 53 mins.
Sound Formats English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 • French Dolby TrueHD 5.1
Subtitles English SDH • English • French
Special Features Director/Cast Audio Commentary; Filmmakers Audio Commentary; Never-Before-Seen Deleted Scenes; "Actors in Search of a Story"; "Building the Team"; "On Location in Chicago"; "On the Set"; "Words on a Page"; "Picture a Number: The Evolution of a G.U.I"; Theatrical Trailers; BD-Live Enabled
Forum Link http://www.avrevforum.com
Reviewer Bill Warren & AVRev.com







Like this article? Bookmark and share with any of the sites below.
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!StumbleUpon!Yahoo!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
 
HDTV Guide Advert

 
  home theater news  |  equipment reviews 
  blu-ray reviews  |  dvd  |  theatrical reviews  
  music download reviews  |  music disc reviews
  contact  |  about-us  |  careers   |  brands 
  Subscribe to Us   |   RSS   |  AVRev Forums
  front page  |  virtual tours  |  dealer locator
  how to features  |   lifestyle & design articles
  Want Your Home Theater Featured on MHT?
   CE Partners: HDD  |  HDF  |  VGT  |  SD  |  DVD
   
  Advertise with Us | Specs | Disclaimer
  Sponsors | privacy policy | terms of use
  909 N. Sepulveda Blvd. El Segundo, CA 90245
  Ads: 310.280.4476 | Contact Us
  Content: 310.280.4575 | Mike Flacy